In the OGC meetings last week WFS Simple was presented to the membership as a part of the “OWS4 GeoDSS Mass Market (formerly GeoRSS) IPR” (note this link will only work for OGC members for a few more days). It was approved as a discussion paper, which is a document that’s worth making public, but is not necessarily an “official” position of the OGC (as a Best Practices paper is).
There were two major areas of discussion at the meeting. One was around whether WFS Simple should harmonize with WFS and become the most basic WFS implementation. The other was related to Basic XML Feature Schema (BXFS) as the default output schema for WFS Simple. These are actually related items as the biggest problem with rolling WFS Simple into WFS would be the issue of having GML as a required output format.
Although at first blush it sounds nice to bring this work into an existing service, I agree with the opinions that it should stay separate. GML as a required output format is too important of a foundation of WFS to tinker with. Therefore I propose maintaining the separation and pursuing the following work items leading to a 1.0 specification.
1. keep WFS Simple focussed on being the generic geospatial data query language for mainstream web data formats like Atom+GeoRSS, KML, etc.
2. Componentize the design of the service, so that this is not really one service, but a simple, clear way to design services focussed on a particular data type like Atom+GeoRSS by adding or removing a parameter or two.
3. Re-emphasize the separation from WFS by moving towards a 1.0 specification with a new name, Geodata Query Service